Well...there seems to be a bit of conflicting viewpoints on this subject, as there should be because, I find myself swapping sided of this argument all the time. Although a few weeks ago I had an epiphany...
We were changing the head gasket on my friends car and suddenly I stared at it and said to myself..."how does a block guard inhibit coolant flow?" If you look at a Honda head gasket the passages for the coolant flow from the block to the head are nothing more than a few holes spaced evenly around the circumference of the cylinder.
The only thing I can think of as far as overheating goes would be that if you used a block guard, and the holes in the block guard didnt match up completely with those of the head gasket, this would seriously impede coolant flow and probably cause overheating....makes sense. However, if a block guard is designed to match these holes perfectly then there should be no reason that this would affect the cooling properties of the block simply due to the fact that even though the block is open deck, the coolant still must pass through small holes in the head gasket to get to the head, so in essence your coolant wouldn't know whether you were running an open or closed deck anyway.
Just something I noticed...is this even worth mentioning, or am I just stating common sense and I'm just too dumb to know any better??:laff: